Forget everything you thought you knew about cookies—Craig's Cookies are in a league of their own, and it's not just hype; it's a phenomenon baked in love, nostalgia, and stuffing! What makes them arguably the best in the world? It starts with the base recipe, passed down from Craig's Newfoundlander mother, delivering that perfect homemade, comforting texture. But the true magic is in the next-level mix-ins! They don't just use chocolate chips; they stuff the cookies with whole, glorious childhood treats like Mars Bars, Mini Eggs, Peanut Butter Cups, and even Pop Tarts! Every bite is an explosion of flavor and texture, gooey, rich, and perfectly balanced with a touch of necessary saltiness that keeps the sweetness from being overwhelming. Beyond the incredible product, the brand's heart is huge! Craig Pike, the founder, built the empire on principles of inclusivity, community, and joy, creating shops that feel like a warm, welcoming visit to your grandmother's kitchen. The sheer number of creative, rotating flavours—over 100 at one point—means there is always something new and exciting. They’ve successfully taken a simple concept and turned it into an unforgettable, community-focused experience. This is more than a cookie; it's a happy pink box of pure delight.
First tried this place in Newfoundland and loved it right away. Everything from the vibes to the cookies themselves. The staff is always wonderful too! You really can’t go wrong with any cookie flavour.
The cookies are amazing, but omg the sodium! I LOVE salt, and these were very rich for me. If you are sensitive to sodium or have dietary sodium needs, avoid. Otherwise sooo tasty
We stopped by Craig’s Cookies in Niagara-on-the-Lake and really enjoyed it. We picked up a half dozen cookies, and each one had great flavour — soft, rich, and made with noticeable care. The shop has a fun, welcoming feel, and the staff were friendly and patient while we chose our mix. A nice stop while walking around downtown NOTL, especially if you’re in the mood for something sweet.
Absolutely delicious cookies and great innovative selection of flavors. 10X better than Crumbl. Was happy to discover there’s so many locations across the GTA. Very cute little box of cookies, $18 for 6 nice size cookies. The Skor was absolutely delicious. And a Glossettes Peanut cookie was pretty cool.
Super mid. Cookies aren’t ‘soft’, they’re underbaked and grainy. Also overpriced. People saying these are the best cookies they’ve had must not have had a cookie from a bakery before.
We had an exceptional experience with this being our 1st visit to this location. The selection of cookies was amazing and the cookies were all beyond delicious. Victoria offered top notch customer service and recommended us a few different places to go and have lunch knowing we were from out of town and not familiar with the area, we didn't even have to ask her. Victoria was very warm, personable and friendly..my husband and I Loved EVERYTHING about this visit. Thank you Victoria Lynn and Tom
Craig's Cookies NOTL is a Canadian Bakery based in Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ontario. Craig's Cookies NOTL is located at 15 Queen St, Niagara-on-the-Lake, ON L0S 1J0, Canada.
Please contact with Craig's Cookies NOTL using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Craig's Cookies NOTL opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.